9 Ways to Create Trust Within Your eCommerce Store

Establishing trust with your customers is a key element to grow & foster long-term relationships with your customers.

It’s so important that I’m sharing with you several ways that my clients establish trust within their eCommerce stores. While also increasing their brand credibility.

Don’t worry, these are easy enough that you can implement them in your own store right away.

Let’s go over ways you can create trust within your eCommerce store.

Make Great First Impressions

Starting with how you welcome your customers to your store. Making a great first impression will set the tone for how customers perceive your products. 

So why not make the best impression possible?

Sometimes it’s hard for us, as business owners, to see our own websites objectively. Simply because we are so close to our business. If you can put your biases aside and look at your website from the point of view of your customers. 

You’ll be able to identify if you have opportunities.

Making a great first impression involves several elements of your website working together. Such as 

  • Your brand voice & tone being in alignment
  • Your visuals cohesively telling your story
  • The flow & overall experience of your website
  • Plus, more

Take an objective view at your site to test if things flow well. If not, it may be time for an eCommerce redesign/rebrand so that you can maximize your online presence.

That will help you create a customer-focused website experience for your business.

Have An Easy to Navigate eCommerce Store

Along the lines of making a great first impression.

Think about how easy it is to navigate your eCommerce store. Reduce any potential friction that could cause your customers to leave your website, quickly.

Some common eCommerce web design mistakes that can cause friction are:

  • A hard to use navigation
  • Too many call-to-actions on a page
  • No clear direction on what to do next
  • Color contrast issues
  • Slow loading pages

Are just some potential friction that can cause customers to not trust that your eCommerce store is credible. We’ve all seen websites that look unprofessional, and then we quickly click off to never return. 

Don’t let that be your website. 

An easy to navigate eCommerce store will help your customers have an enjoyable shopping experience. That allows them to easily checkout and get excited to receive your amazing products. 

Inspire Trust Through Product Reviews

Have you ever been inside of Target or another store and found a product you liked? Then logged on to Amazon to see what other customers have had to say about the product?

I know I have plenty of times and I do this while shopping online from home as well. There is something about getting insights from real customers. 

Often other customers end up sharing feedback that you couldn’t get from the product information itself. 

That makes the buying decision a lot easier.

Product reviews help other customers see genuine experiences. Not that your word isn’t good enough, but sometimes it’s just not. 

Product reviews help reinforce your products value to others

The May Creative

I’ve had some online shop owners not want to display reviews because they didn’t want it to take away from their products. 

Or they just want to keep the style of their site very minimalistic. 

They often come to this conclusion, from checking out other well-known brands who they see aren’t really showing a ton of reviews. 

But what the business owner is failing to realize is … 

That the bigger brand has already put in the effort to build their trust and credibility with their customers. 

Once you’ve built your authority in your market and have consistently provided excellent products. That customers are happily returning for, you can then show up a bit different online.

And even with that extra credibility, you may still want to show your product reviews so that other potential customers understand the quality of what you sell. 

As a minimalist designer myself, I totally get not wanting to bombard your customers with reviews. 

I think there can be a happy middle, with some nice styling that won’t make your site look like it’s being drowned out by reviews.

Showcasing reviews just add that extra incentive for customers to complete a transaction.

Build Trust Via Professional Photos & Video

They say a picture is worth a thousand words. 

Well, fabulous photos and video can sell millions if snapped or shot right. Ever see an ad commercial that shows a desirable lifestyle with their product?

Whether it’s the car commercial that tells you you deserve a luxurious life. Or its Apple sharing how much better life will be with their products instead of without. 

You can bet they sell to our emotions and feelings through video and photos. Most of us become motivated by a better future version of ourselves. 

That is what your customers want when they land on your online store. Help customers envision their life with your products by using great photos and videos that show them what life can be. 

Then pull them in with your words that make them understand that it is better to have lived with your product than without. Yes, I am being a bit dramatic, but sometimes drama sells. Look at reality TV LOL.

Ensure Your Website Aesthetic Is Appealing

As an aesthetic queen myself, it’s the beautiful things, people, and experiences in life that can make living just so much better.

Your website is no exception. More and more merchants are rushing to build their online real estate, and the competition is fierce. 

More consumers will have more options to purchase goods that they potentially didn’t have access to before. Many online stores will sell similar products. So how do you stand out in a busy market?

Well, there are several ways, but one will be your visuals. Yes, I know it may sound vain but our world is a visual space and your eCommerce store aesthetics are no exception. 

Visuals will be the top deciding factor of how your customers establish trust. If your eCommerce store is outdated, those who you want to be on your customer list will not celebrate it. 

Remember, customers buy based on emotions, feelings, and the future version of themselves. 

They don’t want to buy the “just rolled out of bed” look. 

Customers buy the future version of themselves... 

The May Creative

Think about your customers, what attracts them to your business?

Most likely your business is an extension of you, so show up in your best visual outfit. 


Your eCommerce store creates that first impression and will market for you. Even when you are sleeping or off dealing with the other parts of business and life.

Make Sure Your Online Store Loads Fast

Our attention spans are definitely a lot shorter, as we are used to interacting more tech devices each day. 

Plus, we are processing information at a faster rate than what we were years ago. Naturally, people want things to be fast so they can get their information and move on to the next thing. 

The same is said for your eCommerce website. Customers want to navigate quickly through products and read information. Then decide on whether to checkout or leave. 

A fast website makes this process so much easier. 

Here are some ways you can speed up your eCommerce website:

  • Upload appropriately sized photos to your store.
  • If you are using a self-hosted platform like WordPress, use a great premium WP host.
  • Reduce the number of Shopify Apps your using. That will reduce the amount of code your website has to read.

As a web designer & developer, I often see clients want to upload their photos directly from the camera to their website. 

Which is a NO NO. 

Because professional photos are large and often are way larger than you need for your website. Because of the large file size, your website has to download all those extra pixels to display them to your customers. 

Remember, customers don’t have the patience to wait so they will leave. 

Before you upload your product photos or any image to your website. Make sure you have scaled them down to an appropriate size. Sizes will vary based on your theme or template that you are using. 

If you aren’t sure, ask the web developer about the sizes you should use. 

Don’t Forget About Your Mobile Customers

Customers love shopping via their devices.  It’s one piece of technology that is always near them. 

So it makes sense they scour sites on their phones and tablets.  What does that mean for you? That you should validate that your online store is mobile-friendly. 

If it’s not, you’ll run into the increased chances of losing potential customers who will purchase from a store that is mobile friendly.

It’s easy to get super involved in the desktop version of our websites, but neglect the users who visit via smaller screens. 

Regarding mobile, it’s best to not showcase everything on the screen as you would with the desktop version. 

Simply because you don’t want mobile users getting overwhelmed by information and finding themselves scrolling forever. 

Keep only the important information on mobile and hide the extras.

Have An Easy to Understand Return Policy

Customers want to know if the product doesn’t fit their expectations, what type of return policy can they expect. 

You can instill trust and credibility here by making your return policy easy to understand. 

No, I am not saying be super lax about it because each business is unique. But it should be easy to understand by your customers. 

I’ve had instances where I chose not to make a purchase because the return policy made little sense. 

So make your return policy easy to understand and find.

Here are some online store policies you need to have for your luxury brands online store.

Offer Shipping Incentives

Shipping can make or break your customer experience. It’s amazing how you choose to present shipping will determine if your customers make it to checkout.

For example, offering free shipping on orders that are $50 or more. Versus someone spending $40 and paying $5 for shipping. 

Can easily make people click away LOL.

There are major studies around pricing, and I recommend learning a bit more about Pricing Psychology. From how to present prices, whether the extra cents matter, etc. 

Another note on shipping, when you can, make sure it’s clear. That way you reduce the chances of people creating abandoned carts

There are several ways you can up the trust and credibility of your eCommerce store from the visuals down to the pricing structure you implement. 

Remember, your customers want to have an easy to shop experience that is safe. So always think of ways you can reinforce those thoughts for your customers.

karen-founder-tmc 3

Hi, I'm Karen, the founder + strategist/Shopify expert behind The May Creative. I help eCommerce brand owners in luxury, lifestyle and beauty industries craft an elevated Shopify website experience. So they can take their store to the next level. Connect to learn more about working together. Or check out the other articles below and listen to the podcast.


You'll also enjoy with some wine:

  • 3 Strategies to Grow Your eCommerce Store Traffic
  • Benefits Of Live Chat For Your Online Shop
  • Bank More Sales With These eCommerce Web Design Features

Join the conversation